bald reynard Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Could those now recovered after getting back from Pompey, post some player ratings please ? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
davieG Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Portsmouth Viewpoint Carling Cup fourth round at Fratton Park on Tuesday September 21, 2010.POMPEY Jamie Ashdown - Disappointed for goals - 5 Joel Ward - Cracking second half - 7 Carl Dickinson - Plenty of heart - 6 Aaron Mokoena - Stood firm - 7 Ibrahima Sonko - Not bad - 6 Hayden Mullins - Careless at at times - 6 Richard Hughes - Ridiculous dismissal - 5 Liam Lawrence - A rare bright spot - 8 David Nugent*** - Another blank - 5 Kanu* - Still got it - 7 Matt Ritchie** - Struggled - 5 SUBSTITUTES Dave Kitson* (72 mins) Offered something different – 5 Michael Brown** (72 mins) Boosted energy – 6 John Utaka*** (80 mins) Subs not used: Darryl Flahavan, Nadir Ciftci LEICESTER CITY Conrad Logan - Priceless saves - 9 Michael Lamey - Loves to fall around - 5 Michael Morrison - Crucial opener - 7 Angelo Miquel Vitor - So comfortable - 7 Tom Kennedy - Very impressive - 7 Joao Moreno - Classly touches - 7 Yuki Abe - Decent debut - 6 Andy King* - Bossed midfield - 7 Lloyd Dyer*** - So pacey - 7 Paul Gallagher** - Caused problems - 6 Steve Howard - Battering ram - 8 SUBSTITUTES Dany N'Guessan* (66 mins) Added width – 6 Richie Wellens** (72 mins) Franck Moussa*** (90 mins) Subs not used: Chris Weale, Matty Fryatt, Bruno Berner, Jack Hobbs STAR MAN: Liam Lawrence Could have had a hat-trick – nonetheless, Pompey's most creative player and chief goal-scoring threat. MAGIC MOMENT Liam Lawrence crashing home a rare Pompey goal to lift the crowd. LET'S 'AVE HIM: Conrad Logan Reserve keeper thwarted Pompey time and time again with a string of magnificent stops. HE'S ALL YOURS: Michael Lamey Ponderous right-back who's quick to take a tumble, especially with Leicester looking to run down the clock. THE BOSS: Paulo Sousa Impressive first half clinched victory effectively by half-time. MAN IN THE MIDDLE: Fred Graham Dreadful display Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
1884 Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Logan 8* Lamey 6 Morrison 7 Vitor 7 Kennedy 6 Moreno 6 Abe 8 King 8 Dyer 7 Gallagher 6 Howard 7 SUBS N'Guessan 5 Wellens 7 Moussa 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hackneyfox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 I didn't go but from listening on the radio it is beyond me how N'Guessan deserves anything more than 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dpjfox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 what formation did we play? did it chage mid match? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
1884 Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 what formation did we play? did it chage mid match? Logan Lamey Vitor Morrison Kennedy Abe Moreno King Gallagher Dyer Howard Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dpjfox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 should: Weale replace Logan Neilson replace Lamey Berner replace Kennedy who will Hobbs replace will Wellens or Oakley play Will Waghorn or Fryatt play Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Logan 8 MOTM Lamey 6 Morrison 7 Vitor 7 Kennedy 6 Moreno 7.5 Abe 7 King 7 Dyer 7.5 Gallagher 6.5 Howard 7.5 SUBS N'Guessan 5 Wellens 6 Moussa 6 should: Weale replace Logan Neilson replace Lamey Berner replace Kennedy who will Hobbs replace will Wellens or Oakley play Will Waghorn or Fryatt play That's great but your ratings are? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BedsFox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Logan 8* Superb performance, best in a Leicester shirt Lamey 7 Solid as a rock. Not going to offer much going forward, but does his job Morrison 6 Not as solid as he was last year Vitor 7 Looks classy, good reader of the game. Pace. Kennedy 6 Defensively suspect, but bags of potential Moreno 7 Good game I thought, genuine DM but with nice range of passing too Abe 7 Looks too lightweight to be a holding midfielder, but undeniably got all the flicks and skills going forward King 7 Below par, but nice set up for Dyer Dyer 7 Faded again, but ran them ragged first half Gallagher 6 Disappointing. End product please Howard 7 Essential focal point for the breaking midfielders SUBS N'Guessan 5 Ugh, blind alleys and poor decision making Wellens 7 Calmed it down nicely Moussa n/a Thought the four new lads all showed a lot of promise Not sure they are ready yet to play week in week out in the League but can see Vitor over Morrison and Moreno over Oakley soon, and Abe being brought on in time Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corky Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 I didn't go but from listening on the radio it is beyond me how N'Guessan deserves anything more than 2 This. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Munzie Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Logan 8 - Clearly has a point to prove in establishing his 'back-up' status and last nights performance did him the world of good. Solid job with crucial saves. Lamey 6 - Average performance. With Neilson's new found form this season, he should keep Lamey out of the starting 11 until a better replacement is found for both. Morrison 7 - Took his goal well. Looked very nervous at times and could have cost us on a couple of occasions with some wayward back-passes. Vitor 7 - Solid performance, looks promising. Would like to see him partner Hobbs. Kennedy 5 - No where near the finished article. He worried me all night. Got forward well when we were attacking but left us exposed on a few occasions. A loan move would help bring him on. Moreno 5 - Didn't like him as a CB and don't like him in midfield. Other than a couple of decent tackles and occasional through passes, he was error prone. Shame, I was hoping he would have been a real good signing. No evidence of it yet though! Abe 8 - Beginning to get to grips with his team mates and our style of play. Got stuck in and had good vision. Him and Andy King could develop into a very potent midfield pairing. King 7 - Yet another solid performance. It appeared that he had been given instructions to push higher up the pitch. Can only assume that his early departure was to save him for Friday. Dyer 7 - As always, his pace was a major threat. Sometimes lacked the final finish/cross - but a threat nonetheless. Gallagher 6 - Just couldn't seem to get into the game. Would like to see him in a more central role. Howard 7 - Worked hard all night and won pretty much everything. Seems to be working harder than ever this season. Still think he needs to play just behind to two other strikers as his knock-ons aren't always read accurately by a sole partner. SUBS N'Guessan 3 - Why bother? Keeps losing the ball far to easily. Although we have seen brief glimpses of talent in the past, he's way too indifferent. Wellens 6 - A good choice of sub at the time of the game. Helped ensure we started to defend a little better. Made up for his dire performance against QPR. Moussa N/A - Didn't get much of a run-out. Would like to see more of him. (Should keep N'Guessan out of the side). Good atmosphere generated by the travelling faithful. Ref was crap for both sides. Sh*t ground! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 I didn't go but from listening on the radio it is beyond me how N'Guessan deserves anything more than 2 Which is why people shouldn't really review based upon radio coverage. Don't get me wrong, he wasn't great, but 2 is ridiculous Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wycombe Fox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 What Munzie wrote I was going to write my own assessment but I'm busy and I agree with Munzie's ratings apart from Moreno who I'd give a 6 (great 50 yarder!) and N'Guessan who I'd give 8 purely for the accuracy of his first effort on goal which left the stadium at about ten minutes past nine and landed in my front garden about seven miles away at approximately twenty minutes to ten according to Mrs. Isle of Wight Fox. Thanks for the ball Dany. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hackneyfox Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Which is why people shouldn't really review based upon radio coverage. Don't get me wrong, he wasn't great, but 2 is ridiculous So what did he do to warrant a 5 then? With the exception of one move, everything he touched turned to shit. His shot was awful Even Rofe slated him. If he gets 5 then what are you saying about players who get 6 or 7. The scores run from 0 to 10 For you, what would someone have to do to warrant a 0 or 1, shoot the rest of the team? 5 is an average, how can you claim he was average? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kimsalabim Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 Portsmouth Viewpoint Carling Cup fourth round at Fratton Park on Tuesday September 21, 2010.POMPEY Jamie Ashdown - Disappointed for goals - 5 Joel Ward - Cracking second half - 7 Carl Dickinson - Plenty of heart - 6 Aaron Mokoena - Stood firm - 7 Ibrahima Sonko - Not bad - 6 Hayden Mullins - Careless at at times - 6 Richard Hughes - Ridiculous dismissal - 5 Liam Lawrence - A rare bright spot - 8 David Nugent*** - Another blank - 5 Kanu* - Still got it - 7 Matt Ritchie** - Struggled - 5 SUBSTITUTES Dave Kitson* (72 mins) Offered something different – 5 Michael Brown** (72 mins) Boosted energy – 6 John Utaka*** (80 mins) Subs not used: Darryl Flahavan, Nadir Ciftci LEICESTER CITY Conrad Logan - Priceless saves - 9 Michael Lamey - Loves to fall around - 5 Michael Morrison - Crucial opener - 7 Angelo Miquel Vitor - So comfortable - 7 Tom Kennedy - Very impressive - 7 Joao Moreno - Classly touches - 7 Yuki Abe - Decent debut - 6 Andy King* - Bossed midfield - 7 Lloyd Dyer*** - So pacey - 7 Paul Gallagher** - Caused problems - 6 Steve Howard - Battering ram - 8 SUBSTITUTES Dany N'Guessan* (66 mins) Added width – 6 Richie Wellens** (72 mins) Franck Moussa*** (90 mins) Subs not used: Chris Weale, Matty Fryatt, Bruno Berner, Jack Hobbs STAR MAN: Liam Lawrence Could have had a hat-trick – nonetheless, Pompey's most creative player and chief goal-scoring threat. MAGIC MOMENT Liam Lawrence crashing home a rare Pompey goal to lift the crowd. [b]LET'S 'AVE HIM: Conrad Logan[/b]Reserve keeper thwarted Pompey time and time again with a string of magnificent stops. HE'S ALL YOURS: Michael Lamey Ponderous right-back who's quick to take a tumble, especially with Leicester looking to run down the clock. THE BOSS: Paulo Sousa Impressive first half clinched victory effectively by half-time. MAN IN THE MIDDLE: Fred Graham Dreadful display They can 'Ave Em Both. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted 22 September 2010 Share Posted 22 September 2010 So what did he do to warrant a 5 then? With the exception of one move, everything he touched turned to shit. His shot was awful Even Rofe slated him. If he gets 5 then what are you saying about players who get 6 or 7. The scores run from 0 to 10 For you, what would someone have to do to warrant a 0 or 1, shoot the rest of the team? 5 is an average, how can you claim he was average? Perhaps he needed to be on longer to accurately assess his performance, he had a couple of decent runs but you're right in that he wasn't a 5, should've been 4 I guess in relation to my other marks, but giving the guy a 2 from the viewpoint of your radio? Do you not think the commentator's opinion had any influence on your decision to say he's only worth a 2? IMHO for the brief period he was on he was average or slightly below. Are you saying that you're view of his performance was better than mine all the way from Hackney? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.