Muzzy_Larsson Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 (edited) Not a Rodgers bashing post but here are lists of all his signings from his last four clubs for anyone wanting to deep dive into his recruitment and make their own mind up. The point in this post I guess is to use the evidence thus far to make your mind up as to whether or not you'd back him in the transfer market to undertake the rebuild that is undoubtedly coming. Here is a breakdown of his signings at each of his previous clubs. I have left out Reading and Watford and all fees are from transfermrkt. For clarity 'Sales from Rodgers signings' include sales that were made of players he signed even after he'd left the respective club as manager. 'Transfer fees received' are money he brought in from sales in his time as manager at the respective club, whether the players he sold were his signings or not. I have marked asterixes (*) next to those signings have made long term, decent contributions at the respective clubs and who could have been considered a relative success. I've omitted Swansea from this analysis though as my knowledge isn't deep enough there. Swansea Transfer fees spent: £12.47m Transfer fees received: £410k Net Spend: £12.06m Sales from Rodgers signings: £34.7m Scott Sinclair - £540k Leon Britton - £45k Danny Graham - £3.51m Wayne Routledge - £2.93m Leroy Lita - £1.80m Michel Vorm - FC Utrecht - £1.53m Jose Moreira - £765k Darnel Situ - £275k Curtis Obeng - £216k Rory Donnelly - £113k Luke Moore - Free Neil Taylor - Free Ryan Harley - Free Scott Donnelly - Free Gerhard Tremmel - Free Fede Bassone - Free Gylfi Sigurdsson - Loan (Fee was £450k) Tamas Priskin - Loan (Fee was £302k) Fabio Borini - Loan Jermaine Easter - Loan Marvin Emnes - Loan Frank Nouble - Loan Steven Caulker - Loan Josh McEachran - Loan Liverpool Transfer fees spent: £296.55m Transfer fees received: £118.59m Net Spend: £177.96m Sales from Rodgers signings: £265.95m Fabio Borini - £10.4m Joe Allen - £15m* Oussama Assaidi - £3m Samed Yesil - £1m Daniel Sturridge - £12m* Phillipe Coutinho - £8.5m* Luis Alberto - £6.8m Iago Aspas - £7.0m Simon Mignolet - £9.0m* Mamadou Sakho - £15.0m* Tiago Llori - £3.5m Rickie Lambert - £4.5m Adam Lallana - £25.0m* Emre Can - £9.75m* Lazar Markovic - £19.8m Dejan Lovren - £20.0m* Divock Origi - £9.8m* Alberto Moreno - £12m Mario Balotelli - £16m Joe Gomez - £6m* Danny Ings - £8m Nathaniel Clyne - £12m* Roberto Firmino - £29.0m* Christian Benteke - £32.5m James Milner - Free* Adam Bogdan - Free Kolo Toure - Free* Kevin Stewart - Free Nuri Sahin - Loan Aly Cissokho - Loan Victor Moses - Loan Javier Manquillo - Loan Celtic Transfer fees spent: £31.76m Transfer fees received: £29.35m Net Spend: £2.41m Sales from Rodgers signings: £17.01m (Bulk of this was the Edouard sale from this summer after he left) * I've not included Moussa Dembele as a Rodgers signing or as a 'Sale from Rodgers signing' as this deal was agreed prior to his arrival Scott Sinclair - £3.69m* Eboue Kouassi - £3.15m Cristian Gamboa - £1.0m Olivier Ntcham - £4.5m* Charly Musonda - Loan (Fee was £2.25m) Jack Hendry - £1.44m Johnny Hayes - £1.32m Marven Compper - £1.03m Lewis Morgan - £300k Odsonne Edouard - £9.27m* Vakoun Bayo - £2.01m Maryan Shved - £1.80m Kolo Toure - Free Dorus De Vries - Free Scott Bain - Free* Youssouf Mulumbu - Free Manny Perez - Free Andrew Gutman - Free Emillio Izzaguire - Free Kundai Benyu - Free Patrick Roberts - Loan* Filip Benkovic - Loan* Daniel Arzani - Loan Jeremy Toljan - Loan Timothy Weah - Loan Oliver Burke - Loan Leicester Transfer fees spent: £208.8m Transfer fees received: £130.75m Net Spend: £78.05m Sales from Rodgers signings: £0m Youri Tielemens - £40.5m* Ayoze Perez - £31.5m Dennis Praet - £17.28m James Justin - £6.03m* Wesley Fofana - £31.5m* Timothy Castagne - £18.0m* Patson Daka - £27.0m Boubakary Soumare - £18.0m Jannik Vestergaard - £15.84m Ryan Bertrand - Free Cenguz Under - Loan (Fee was £3.15m) Ryan Bennett - Loan Ademola Lookman - Loan Daka, Soumare and Lookman are not long in the door and aren't bad signings it's just too early to consider them a success or failure yet imo. Edited 24 February 2022 by Muzzy_Larsson 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Greg2607 Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 5 minutes ago, Muzzy_Larsson said: Not a Rodgers bashing post but here are lists of all his signings from his last four clubs for anyone wanting to deep dive into his recruitment and make their own mind up. The point in this post I guess is to use the evidence thus far to make your mind up as to whether or not you'd back him in the transfer market to undertake the rebuild that is undoubtedly coming. Here is a breakdown of his signings at each of his previous clubs. I have left out Reading and Watford and all fees are from transfermrkt. For clarity 'Sales from Rodgers signings' include sales that were made of players he signed even after he'd left the respective club as manager. 'Transfer fees received' are money he brought in from sales in his time as manager at the respective club, whether the players he sold were his signings or not. Swansea Transfer fees spent: £12.47m Transfer fees received: £410k Net Spend: £12.06m Sales from Rodgers signings: £34.7m Scott Sinclair - £540k Leon Britton - £45k Danny Graham - £3.51m Wayne Routledge - £2.93m Leroy Lita - £1.80m Michel Vorm - FC Utrecht - £1.53m Jose Moreira - £765k Darnel Situ - £275k Curtis Obeng - £216k Rory Donnelly - £113k Luke Moore - Free Neil Taylor - Free Ryan Harley - Free Scott Donnelly - Free Gerhard Tremmel - Free Fede Bassone - Free Gylfi Sigurdsson - Loan (Fee was £450k) Tamas Priskin - Loan (Fee was £302k) Fabio Borini - Loan Jermaine Easter - Loan Marvin Emnes - Loan Frank Nouble - Loan Steven Caulker - Loan Josh McEachran - Loan Liverpool Transfer fees spent: £296.55m Transfer fees received: £118.59m Net Spend: £177.96m Sales from Rodgers signings: £265.95m Fabio Borini - £10.4m Joe Allen - £15m Oussama Assaidi - £3m Samed Yesil - £1m Daniel Sturridge - £12m Phillipe Coutinho - £8.5m Luis Alberto - £6.8m Iago Aspas - £7.0m Simon Mignolet - £9.0m Mamadou Sakho - £15.0m Tiago Llori - £3.5m Rickie Lambert - £4.5m Adam Lallana - £25.0m Emre Can - £9.75m Lazar Markovic - £19.8m Dejan Lovren - £20.0m Divock Origi - £9.8m Alberto Moreno - £12m Mario Balotelli - £16m Joe Gomez - £6m Danny Ings - £8m Nathaniel Clyne - £12m Roberto Firmino - £29.0m Christian Benteke - £32.5m James Milner - Free Adam Bogdan - Free Kolo Toure - Free Kevin Stewart - Free Nuri Sahin - Loan Aly Cissokho - Loan Victor Moses - Loan Javier Manquillo - Loan Celtic Transfer fees spent: £31.76m Transfer fees received: £29.35m Net Spend: £2.41m Sales from Rodgers signings: £17.01m (Bulk of this was the Edouard sale from this summer after he left) * I've not included Moussa Dembele as a Rodgers signing or as a 'Sale from Rodgers signing' as this deal was agreed prior to his arrival Scott Sinclair - £3.69m Eboue Kouassi - £3.15m Cristian Gamboa - £1.0m Olivier Ntcham - £4.5m Charly Musonda - Loan (Fee was £2.25m) Jack Hendry - £1.44m Johnny Hayes - £1.32m Marven Compper - £1.03m Lewis Morgan - £300k Odsonne Edouard - £9.27m Vakoun Bayo - £2.01m Maryan Shved - £1.80m Kolo Toure - Free Dorus De Vries - Free Scott Bain - Free Youssouf Mulumbu - Free Manny Perez - Free Andrew Gutman - Free Emillio Izzaguire - Free Kundai Benyu - Free Patrick Roberts - Loan Filip Benkovic - Loan Daniel Arzani - Loan Jeremy Toljan - Loan Timothy Weah - Loan Oliver Burker - Loan Leicester Transfer fees spent: £208.8m Transfer fees received: £130.75m Net Spend: £78.05m Sales from Rodgers signings: £0m Youri Tielemens - £40.5m Ayoze Perez - £31.5m Dennis Praet - £17.28m James Justin - £6.03m Wesley Fofana - £31.5m Timothy Castagne - £18.0m Patson Daka - £27.0m Boubakary Soumare - £18.0m Jannik Vestergaard - £15.84m Ryan Bertrand - Free Cenguz Under - Loan (Fee was £3.15m) Ryan Bennett - Loan Ademola Lookman - Loan so what we are basically seeing is that the clubs have always recovered less than he has spent on players effectively. even the liverpool ones are sweked as there was the massive coutinho fee to mask some of the resale value. that's excellent news. something to look forward to then! lol. Saying that... I wonder if that's the same at most clubs generally... no idea how it compares. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Muzzy_Larsson Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 6 minutes ago, Greg2607 said: so what we are basically seeing is that the clubs have always recovered less than he has spent on players effectively. even the liverpool ones are sweked as there was the massive coutinho fee to mask some of the resale value. that's excellent news. something to look forward to then! lol. Saying that... I wonder if that's the same at most clubs generally... no idea how it compares. Yeah I had the same observations when I put the post together and also like yourself, have no idea how it compares to other clubs. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MattFox Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 3 years since we sacked Puel today 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sankey93 Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Hopefully after this dreadful performance we sack Brendan. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jonezy Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Too many of these horror shows. Enough is enough. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StanSP Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Just now, Sankey93 said: Hopefully after this dreadful performance we sack Brendan. What? Gets us advancing through to the next round and that's the game that does it? Yeah course. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mendi Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Club will not sack him. John Percy did a story on it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Unabomber Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 1 minute ago, Sankey93 said: Hopefully after this dreadful performance we sack Brendan. Yeah hopefully been horrific tonight. Can’t hide behind a couple of great goals by Maddison. It’s the performance that is a serious cause for concern. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Year Of The Fox Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 1 minute ago, StanSP said: What? Gets us advancing through to the next round and that's the game that does it? Yeah course. Whilst I agree with you, Ranieri had a superb result in Sevilla, and got binned the next day. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
coolhandfox Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Writing in on the wall. Matter of time. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StanSP Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Just now, The Year Of The Fox said: Whilst I agree with you, Ranieri had a superb result in Sevilla, and got binned the next day. True, but if they wanted to sack him, they'd have done it by now. I still maintain that the moment we get knocked out of Europe, he goes. Objective would have been to qualify for Europe next season. The moment that because impossible, he's out. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ttfn Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Just now, Unabomber said: Yeah hopefully been horrific tonight. Can’t hide behind a couple of great goals by Maddison. It’s the performance that is a serious cause for concern. People were saying this as far back as October, there was a thread about it where somebody was basically laughed at for the fact that they suggested that it might be a problem that we only seemed to be scoring screamers - this was a period in October where Tielemans scored 2 ridiculous goals against United and Brentford, Vardy scored a belter against United and Barnes against Leeds. Even going back to the opening day Vardy scored a goal that almost no other player in the league would have scored. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Stuntman_Mike Posted 24 February 2022 Popular Post Share Posted 24 February 2022 1 minute ago, coolhandfox said: Writing in on the wall. Matter of time. I agree. Managers don't survive this level of performance for this amount of time 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Unabomber Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Just now, ttfn said: People were saying this as far back as October, there was a thread about it where somebody was basically laughed at for the fact that they suggested that it might be a problem that we only seemed to be scoring screamers - this was a period in October where Tielemans scored 2 ridiculous goals against United and Brentford, Vardy scored a belter against United and Barnes against Leeds. Even going back to the opening day Vardy scored a goal that almost no other player in the league would have scored. I think I remember that and I was one of those who laughed, oh how naive I was. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
winteriscoming Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Imo he goes if we lose to Burnley. 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tetly Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 When we make Burnley look like Barcelona he goes in my opinion. You can’t paper over the cracks. Something isn’t right we are all over the place defensively. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bozman Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 5 minutes ago, winteriscoming said: Imo he goes if we lose to Burnley. And we will...They are a bit too physical for our lot.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tanya Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 18 minutes ago, Sankey93 said: Hopefully after this dreadful performance we sack Brendan. It was an awful performance but you don't sack a manager after we have easily won a tie. Come on now. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lcfc82 Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 10 minutes ago, winteriscoming said: Imo he goes if we lose to Burnley. If we don’t beat them or Leeds I don’t see how he keeps his job. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mickyblueeyes Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 The mans struggling. Long gone. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oxtonfox Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 We’re stuck with Rodgers, sadly for the season. He should go in the summer. 3 years is long enough these days. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
teblin Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Someone said it was like the randers cup final. We looked like we struggled with the conditions, but we won 3-1. it was poor but we have just won the tie 7-2 can’t see that as basis for sacking him. Having said that if we don’t get results against both Leeds and Burnley he may well be in big trouble. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bourbon Fox Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 1 minute ago, teblin said: Someone said it was like the randers cup final. We looked like we struggled with the conditions, but we won 3-1. it was poor but we have just won the tie 7-2 can’t see that as basis for sacking him. Having said that if we don’t get results against both Leeds and Burnley he may well be in big trouble. Problem is, if we'd put in that performance against league opposition we'd have been 3-1 down by the half hour Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Beachyboy Posted 24 February 2022 Share Posted 24 February 2022 Brendan's eyes in that interview, he knows he's gone, it's just a case of when and saving face, I don't think he will survive until the summer, Puel went in game 27 after losing by a goal to Wolves in Game 23, I think Brendan will go in game 27 after Loss to Burnley, Win v Leeds, Lose Arsenal, Lose Brentford. 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts