Ric Flair Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Yep. Would add Kilgallon and Shittu to that list. Kevin Foley is a good defender as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The People's Hero Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Jason Shackell. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Kevin Foley is a good defender as well. Almost as good as Franck Rolling. I'm really bored. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ric Flair Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Almost as good as Franck Rolling.I'm really bored. Ring the club up and pretend to be Peter Reid, so how far you get. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Geo V Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Darren Purse Danny Mills Madjid Bougherra Sam Sodje Elliot Ward Graham Alexander Bruno N'Gotty Gary Naysmith Chris Morgan Frankie Simek Jay DeMerit Paul Robinson Leon Barnett Neil Clement I'd say those above are every bit as good as Kisnorbo, other than Paddy scores more goals than most of them. I should have asked you to name players who are better in Kisnorbo`s position as CB as you have put quite a few fullbacks on that list like Simek, Mills, Alexander, Clement and Naysmith. From the rest I don't think that Danny Mills is a better CB. Maybe a better RB. I think from your list I`d say Chris Morgan was as good if not a tad better, Jay DeMerit is a good solid player too and Sam Sodje has got good ability but nothing on that list is stand-out and are far as I can see although I must admit to knowing little about Leon Barnett. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dames Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Kisnorbo is a good defender. If he worked on things such as his distribution a little more he would be up there with the best in the league. And McAuley should aswell it frustrates me how much these two hoof it they should watch N'Gotty and learn how its done. Otherwise we have 2 perfectly able centerbacks (Kisnorbo and McAuley) and 1 class act (N'Gotty) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ric Flair Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I should have asked you to name players who are better in Kisnorbo`s position as CB as you have put quite a few fullbacks on that list like Simek, Mills, Alexander, Clement and Naysmith. From the rest I don't think that Danny Mills is a better CB. Maybe a better RB.I think from your list I`d say Chris Morgan was as good if not a tad better, Jay DeMerit is a good solid player too and Sam Sodje has got good ability but nothing on that list is stand-out and are far as I can see although I must admit to knowing little about Leon Barnett. Purse, N'Gotty, Morgan, DeMerit, Shittu, Barnett, Bougherra, Ward, Sodje are all centre halves and are every bit as good as Kisnorbo defense wise. What Paddy has over all of them is the ability to score goals on a fairly regular basis. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The People's Hero Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I think we should take a moment to consider the fact that Charlton paid us £650 for McCarthy! Hahahahahahahaha! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Ring the club up and pretend to be Peter Reid, so how far you get. That's the best idea I've ever heard today. My lunch break is pretty much over though. I'll do it tomorrow. We'll probably have appointed the c**t by then though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The People's Hero Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 That's the best idea I've ever heard today.My lunch break is pretty much over though. I'll do it tomorrow. We'll probably have appointed the c**t by then though. Ring up and pretend to be Dennis Wise. Ask about having Elvis on loan. Please? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Ring up and pretend to be Dennis Wise. Ask about having Elvis on loan.Please? Again, a fine plan. But I am out of time. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Reverend Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Darren Purse - OK, probably.Danny Mills - Yes Madjid Bougherra - No he is average at best and was a panic buy by Charlton while they were in the Prem. Sam Sodje - Yeah probably just edges it. Elliot Ward - No. Graham Alexander - Yes. Bruno N'Gotty - Yes Gary Naysmith - Maybe. Chris Morgan - Proabably. Frankie Simek - No chance. Jay DeMerit - Not after his performance against us. Before i saw that game id of said he would of slightly edged it, but after that no. Paul Robinson - Yes. Leon Barnett - Dont think so. Neil Clement - Yes. But a few of them are full backs anyway. I'd say those above are every bit as good as Kisnorbo, other than Paddy scores more goals than most of them. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Daggers Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Sodje is a cock with no sense of position. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Geo V Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Purse, N'Gotty, Morgan, DeMerit, Shittu, Barnett, Bougherra, Ward, Sodje are all centre halves and are every bit as good as Kisnorbo defense wise. What Paddy has over all of them is the ability to score goals on a fairly regular basis. I agree that some names on that list are as good as Kisnorbo but the standard is so low that there are not that many better and it shows how far the club have come since last summer because we wouldn't have a 2nd player in most peoples top ten defenders in the division. I personally think that McAuley is better than both of our aforementioned players as out and out defenders! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Sodje is a cock with no sense of position. :laugh: Sure you're not getting him mixed up with Efe Sodje, the woeful Southend defender? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ric Flair Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 That's the best idea I've ever heard today.My lunch break is pretty much over though. I'll do it tomorrow. We'll probably have appointed the c**t by then though. I've just called the ticket office and pretended to be Efan Ekoku, I said I needed 20 tickets for Saturday's game for my family who will be attending to see their father in his first game in charge. They were keen. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Daggers Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 :laugh: Sure you're not getting him mixed up with Efe Sodje, the woeful Southend defender? That is, of course, to whom I was referring. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ttfn Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Darren Purse Danny Mills Madjid Bougherra Sam Sodje Elliot Ward Graham Alexander Bruno N'Gotty Gary Naysmith Chris Morgan Frankie Simek Jay DeMerit Paul Robinson Leon Barnett Neil Clement I'd say those above are every bit as good as Kisnorbo, other than Paddy scores more goals than most of them. I'm sorry I just can't agree with the vast majority of names on that list. Mills used to be good, now is not. Bougherra, as someone else has said, was a panic buy. Ward - don't make me laugh. Alexander - old, slow, experienced but that's it. He just scores a lot of goals cos he takes pens so gets a lot of press coverage (relatively speaking). If he was any good, would Preston have sold him to Burnley?! N'Gotty is not as good as PK any more, but remains a very assured defender. Naysmith is a better player than PK, but is not as good defensively as him. So PK is the better 'defender'. Morgan is a thug, but not a bad one, I'd put him on a par with PK. Simek - that's a total joke. DeMerit - Just not as good. Never been convinced by him, people are seduced by his zero to hero story. Robinson - yes, he is a better defender. Barnett - was awesome against us last year, not seen enough to be sure. Clement - used to be better than PK, not any more, he doesn't even start regularly for WBA!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Manwell Pablo Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 :laugh: Sure you're not getting him mixed up with Efe Sodje, the woeful Southend defender? Theres bucket loads of em, all from the same family, scattered throughout Proffesional and Semi proffesional football. Can't blame poor old Daggers for getting mixed up. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Theres bucket loads of em, all from the same family, scattered throughout Proffesional and Semi proffesional football. Can't blame poor old Daggers for getting mixed up. There's even one in rugby league. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Daggers Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I AM FUCKING ILL - and have only had just over an hours sleep in the last 24 hours Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dr The Singh Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I AM FUCKING ILL - and have only had just over an hours sleep in the last 24 hours Is that Kisnorbo's fault???? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I AM FUCKING ILL - and have only had just over an hours sleep in the last 24 hours Easy tiger. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ric Flair Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 I AM FUCKING ILL - and have only had just over an hours sleep in the last 24 hours Is that an anagram for our next manager? Ray Illingworth? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fez of Mahrez Posted 10 September 2007 Share Posted 10 September 2007 Is that an anagram for our next manager? Ray Illingworth? King William IV?! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.